Key takeaways
- Editing works from big to small: structure first, then style, then grammar, then a final check.
- Developmental editing looks at plot, pacing and structure. Line editing shapes sentences. Copy editing fixes grammar and consistency.
- Proofreading is the last check. It does not replace editing.
- Different editors use different names for the same work, so always ask what a service includes.
- A cleaner manuscript may need a lighter edit.
Why editing happens in stages
Editing is not one job. A book can have a weak middle, clumsy sentences and typos all at once. Fixing them together wastes effort.
If an editor rewrites a chapter, earlier typo fixes there are wasted. So editors work from the largest problems to the smallest. Editors Canada, the national association for editors, describes these stages in its Professional Editorial Standards.
The standards also note that stages can overlap or be combined. Some projects mix two stages because of budget or time.
The types of book editing at a glance
| Type | What it looks at | When it happens |
|---|---|---|
| Manuscript assessment | The whole book, in broad strokes | Before editing starts |
| Developmental editing | Structure, plot, pacing, content | First editing stage |
| Line editing | Style, flow, voice, sentences | After structure is set |
| Copy editing | Grammar, spelling, punctuation, consistency | After line editing |
| Proofreading | Final typos and layout errors | After the book is laid out |
Manuscript assessment
A manuscript assessment is when an editor reads your whole book and tells you what it needs. Ask what the assessment includes, since services differ.
It is a good first step if you are unsure what stage your book needs. It can also save money, because it shows you where to spend.
Developmental editing
Developmental editing is feedback on plot, pacing and structure. Editors Canada calls the same work structural editing. It notes that structural editing is also called substantive editing, and that structural editing combined with stylistic editing is sometimes called manuscript editing.
Its definition says the editor assesses and shapes the overall organization and content so the book suits its audience and purpose.
For a novel, that may mean fixing a slow middle or a confusing timeline. For nonfiction, it may mean reordering chapters so your argument builds.
Do this stage first. There is no point polishing sentences you may cut.
Line editing
Line editing is sentence-level style and flow. The editor smooths clunky wording, tightens paragraphs and keeps your voice consistent.
Editors Canada says stylistic editing focuses on clarity, coherence and flow, and polishes the language. It adds that line editing is often understood as a mix of stylistic editing and copy editing.
That blend is why services differ. Always ask what a company means by the term.
Copy editing
Copy editing is a check for grammar, consistency and clarity. A copy editor fixes spelling, punctuation and usage. They also catch slips such as a character's eye color changing or a name spelled two ways.
Editors Canada notes that people often use "copy editing" loosely to cover other tasks. It uses the term only in its narrower sense of correct, consistent language.
Line editing vs copy editing
The difference is the goal. Line editing asks, "Does this read well?" Copy editing asks, "Is this correct and consistent?"
Many books get both. Some tight budgets combine them into one pass.
Proofreading a book
Proofreading is the final check for typos and punctuation. It happens after your book is laid out, in its final form.
Editors Canada says proofreading checks work after editing. It is not a substitute for editing. A proofreader should not start heavier editing unless you ask for it.
Proofreading catches problems that appear in layout too, such as a bad line break or a missing page number.
Which type of book editing does your book need?
Start with the state of your manuscript. Editors Canada's blog notes that a manuscript with major issues will likely need a developmental or substantive edit. A relatively clean one may need only a proofread or light copy edit.
Use this as a rough guide:
- Unsure where you stand: start with a manuscript assessment.
- Structure feels shaky: developmental editing first.
- Structure is solid but sentences are rough: line editing.
- Writing is strong, but you want it polished: copy editing, then proofreading.
- Already edited and laid out: proofreading.
You do not always need every stage. But skipping stages carries risk. Readers notice errors.
Read our guide on how to prepare a manuscript for publishing before you hire anyone. For prices, see book editing cost in Canada.
How to work with an editor at each stage
Each stage needs a clear brief. Tell the editor what you want and what worries you.
Editors Toronto advises sharing a sample of your document so the editor can estimate the scope, price and time. Editors Canada also recommends a written agreement that sets out fees, reimbursements and deadlines.
What to ask before you hire
- Which stage does this service cover, and what does it leave out?
- Will I get notes, tracked changes or both?
- How many rounds of changes are included?
- Do you offer a sample edit of a few pages?
Ask these questions even when a service uses familiar names. As Editors Canada points out, terms like copy editing are often used loosely.
How to know a stage is finished
Each stage should leave your book in better shape for the next one. After developmental editing, the structure should hold. After line editing, the voice should feel steady.
After copy editing, the language should be correct and consistent. After proofreading, the pages should be ready to print.
Frequently asked questions
The main types are developmental editing, line editing, copy editing and proofreading. Many editors also offer a manuscript assessment first. Each stage works on a different level, from structure down to typos.
Developmental editing improves the big picture: plot, structure and pacing. Copy editing fixes grammar, spelling and consistency. Developmental editing comes first.
No. Proofreading is a final check on a finished, laid-out book. Editors Canada says it is not a substitute for editing.
Not always. A clean manuscript may need only copy editing and proofreading. A rough draft usually needs developmental editing first.
Go from big to small: assessment or developmental editing, then line editing, then copy editing, then proofreading. Each stage prepares the book for the next.
How JEO can help
JEO Publishing offers manuscript assessment, developmental editing, line editing, copy editing and proofreading as single services. Our packages add stages as they go up. Manuscript Blueprint includes a manuscript assessment and proofreading.
You keep 100% of your copyright, and a Publishing Manager is your main contact during production and for 30 days after publication.
Sources
- Editors Canada, Professional Editorial Standards and Professional Editorial Standards 2024 (PDF) (definitions of structural, stylistic and copy editing and proofreading; stages can overlap)
- Editors Canada, Definitions of editorial skills (2019) (alternate terms such as substantive and language editing)
- Editors Canada, The Editors' Weekly, Preparing for Traditional Publishing: Tips from Agents and Editors (a clean manuscript may need only a light edit)
- JEO Publishing, Publishing packages (package inclusions)
