Key takeaways
- Traditional publishers pay for production and choose which books to publish. You give up some control.
- Self-publishing means you pay for production and make the decisions. You keep your rights.
- Royalty rates differ a lot. Always check what the rate is based on.
- A literary agent helps you reach traditional publishers. You do not need one to self publish.
- "Hybrid publishing" has no legal definition, so check any company carefully.
What is traditional publishing?
In traditional publishing, a publisher accepts your book and pays to produce it. Most large publishers expect submissions through a literary agent. An agent is a professional who sells your book to publishers and negotiates your contract.
The publisher usually pays you an advance. An advance is money paid upfront, against the royalties your book may earn later. In your contract, you agree to license certain rights to the publisher.
What is self publishing?
In self-publishing, you publish the book yourself. You pay for editing, design and distribution, or you hire a company to do it. You choose the title, cover, price and release date.
You keep your copyright. Platforms like Amazon KDP and IngramSpark print and sell your book. Read our how to self publish a book guide for the steps.
Self publishing vs traditional publishing: side by side
| Traditional | Self-publishing | |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays for production | The publisher | You |
| Upfront payment | Often an advance | None |
| Who decides cover, title, price | Mostly the publisher | You |
| Rights | You license rights to the publisher | You keep your rights |
| Agent needed | Usually | No |
| Speed | Slower, with steps in sequence | You set the schedule |
| Your share per sale | A smaller percentage | A larger percentage |
Rights and control
Your copyright starts as yours. In Canada, it applies automatically when you create your work.
With a traditional deal, you license rights, such as print, ebook, audio and translation, for a set area and time. The contract decides what you keep. Read it with care, or ask a lawyer or a writers' organization to review it.
With self-publishing, you decide everything. You also carry every decision, mistake and cost.
Do you need a literary agent?
For most large traditional publishers, yes. An agent pitches your book, negotiates the deal and takes a commission on what you earn. Watch for any agent who asks for upfront fees, and check their sales record.
You do not need an agent to self publish. You do not need one for some small presses, which sometimes accept direct submissions.
Timelines in general terms
Traditional publishing has many steps in a row. You find an agent, the agent submits, a publisher decides, and then editing and scheduling follow. Each step can take time, and there are no guarantees.
With self-publishing, the timeline depends on you and your team. Editing and design usually take the longest. Our guide on how to publish a book in Canada shows the stages in order.
What is hybrid publishing?
Hybrid publishing sits between the two. A hybrid publisher shares costs with the author, and in return may offer higher royalties and some publishing services.
The term has no legal definition. Some companies use it to make a pay-to-publish service sound like traditional publishing.
The Independent Book Publishers Association (IBPA) has published criteria for reputable hybrid publishers. They include vetting submissions and meeting professional quality standards. Its standards are guidelines, not law.
Ask any company these questions:
- Who owns my copyright and ISBNs?
- What do I pay, and what do I get for it?
- Can I leave, and do I get my files back?
- Do you choose books by quality, or accept anyone who pays?
Comparing companies? Use our checklist for self-publishing companies in Canada.
Which should you choose?
Choose traditional publishing if you want a publisher's support and are willing to wait and give up some control. Choose self-publishing if you want control, speed and your rights. Consider a services route if you want expert help and still want to own your book.
None of these routes guarantees sales. Your goals should drive the choice.
Frequently asked questions
Neither is better for every author. Self-publishing gives you control and a bigger share per sale.
Traditional publishing gives you a team and often an advance. Pick the one that fits your goals and budget.
Yes. You keep your copyright when you self publish. If you use a company's services, check the contract to confirm you keep your rights and ISBNs.
It varies by contract and format. The Authors Guild says the traditional hardcover royalty is 15% of list price, and ebooks commonly pay 25% of net receipts. Check what each rate is based on.
Some authors do, but nothing guarantees an offer. Publishers look at the book and your track record. If you already have a self-published title, you may need to keep it available or take it down, depending on the deal.
Some hybrid publishers are reputable, and some are not. The term has no legal meaning. Check the contract, the rights and what you pay.
How JEO can help
Not sure which route fits your book? Our consulting team can walk you through your options in a one-hour strategy session for $120. JEO Publishing is a self-publishing company, not a traditional publisher, so you keep 100% of your copyright and your ISBNs. You can also compare our publishing packages.
Sources
- Authors Guild, Half of net proceeds is the fair royalty rate for e-books (hardcover 15% of list; ebook net royalty)
- Authors Guild, Model Trade Book Contract (ebook 25% of net receipts)
- The Writers' Union of Canada, Study on the Remuneration of Writers (2017) and Model Trade Book Contract
- Amazon KDP, eBook Royalties, eBook List Price Requirements and Self Publishing: print royalties
- Kobo Writing Life, royalty help article
- Canadian Intellectual Property Office, Copyright
- Authors Guild, IBPA releases criteria for hybrid publishing and Publishers Weekly, IBPA revises hybrid publisher criteria
